Evaluating the ‘Oh Crap’ Method: Best Choice for Potty Training?

We may receive compensation from the providers of the services and products featured on this website. Read our Advertising Disclosure.

Navigating the intricate path of potty training can be a daunting task for modern parents, yet the ‘Oh Crap’ Potty Training method, crafted by Jamie Glowacki, promises a structured yet flexible approach. This method, recommended for children between 20 and 30 months, emphasizes the importance of recognizing and responding to bodily cues, aiming to cultivate a child’s independence and self-confidence in this critical developmental stage. It’s not just about moving away from diapers; it’s about fostering trust and autonomy in your child during their potty training journey.

In delving into the ‘Oh Crap’ method compared to other potty training techniques, this article will explore the step-by-step blocks laid out by Glowacki, designed to ease both child and parent through this transformative process. From the first day to mastering use at night, navigating public restrooms, and handling potential regressions, we uncover the advantages, challenges, and real experiences of parents who have embarked on this journey. The goal is to provide an authoritative guide on whether the ‘Oh Crap’ method stands as the most effective approach for the modern potty training experience.

Understanding the ‘Oh Crap’ Potty Training Method

The ‘Oh Crap’ Potty Training Method, developed by Jamie Glowacki, is a structured yet adaptable approach designed to guide children aged between 20 and 30 months through the transition from diapers to using the toilet independently. This method is outlined in Glowacki’s book, “Oh Crap! Potty Training,” which provides a detailed framework divided into several progressive blocks, each tailored to accommodate the child’s learning pace and the parent’s observation skills.

Block Structure Overview

  1. Block One: Focuses on the child learning to pee and poop while naked, which lasts about four days. This stage involves close observation by the parent to help the child associate the act with the sensation.
  2. Block Two: Introduces clothing (without underwear) to the child, encouraging them to continue their toilet habits with the added complexity of clothes, and includes short outings to test skills in public settings.
  3. Block Three: Expands the child’s adaptability to pee and poop under various conditions, with or without prompting, helping them manage different environments and potential resistance.
  4. Block Four: Involves the child wearing underpants and mastering the earlier learned skills with the added challenge of more restrictive clothing.
  5. Block Five: Aims for the child to begin initiating going to the potty without prompts.
  6. Block Six: Addresses nighttime and naptime training, acknowledging that occasional prompting might still be necessary.
  7. Block Seven: Known humorously as ‘College’, this final block reinforces that while the child may be proficient, occasional reminders are still part of the process.

Key Features and Practicality

The method emphasizes a no-reward system, arguing that children should view toilet use as a normal part of life rather than a task that earns them treats. This approach helps normalize potty use without relying on external rewards. Additionally, the method is praised for its practicality and simplicity, requiring minimal equipment—often just a potty chair—and allowing families to avoid costly training products. Parents are advised to start with a clear schedule, typically choosing a long weekend or a period without daycare, to dedicate time to assist their child through the initial, more demanding phases of the training.

This method not only supports the child through a significant developmental milestone but also encourages parents to engage deeply with their child’s cues and needs, fostering a supportive environment conducive to learning. The ‘Oh Crap’ Method’s step-by-step guide through its block system offers a clear path forward for parents seeking an effective potty training strategy.

The Advantages of the ‘Oh Crap’ Method

The ‘Oh Crap’ Potty Training Method stands out for its flexibility and ease of use, which are crucial for modern parents navigating the challenges of potty training. One of the primary benefits is the minimal equipment required—often just a potty chair—allowing families to manage the potty training process without the need for expensive and extensive gear. This simplicity is not only cost-effective but also reduces the clutter and stress associated with managing numerous training aids.

Moreover, the method empowers children by teaching them to recognize and respond to their body’s cues. This promotes a sense of body awareness and independence, crucial for their development. The gradual transition from diapers to using the potty also significantly reduces stress and anxiety, making the experience more positive for both children and parents. The approach fosters an open line of communication between parent and child, enhancing understanding and making it easier to navigate this developmental phase together.

Parents who have adopted the ‘Oh Crap’ method often highlight the importance of consistency and the method’s ability to adapt to different family dynamics and routines. Whether it’s during short outings or regular daily activities, the method encourages a routine that fits seamlessly into the family’s lifestyle. This adaptability, combined with the structured guidance provided in Jamie Glowacki’s book, helps many families achieve potty training success, leading to greater independence not just for the child but for the entire family, ultimately enhancing their overall quality of life.

Challenges and Criticisms

While the ‘Oh Crap’ Potty Training Method offers a structured approach, it also presents several challenges and criticisms that may influence its effectiveness for different families. One significant concern is the intensive commitment required during the initial blocks, where parents must closely monitor and frequently escort their child to the potty. This can be particularly demanding as it necessitates a parent or caregiver to be constantly available, potentially disrupting regular work schedules and leading to possible hygiene issues as young children learn to control their bodily functions.

Moreover, the method’s strict guidelines can clash with external schedules, especially in settings like daycare, where specific potty training policies may not accommodate the ‘Oh Crap’ method’s requirements. Such conflicts may result in scheduling difficulties, complicating the training process for both children and parents. Additionally, the method presupposes a level of readiness and cooperation from the child, which might not always be present. Resistance from children, whether due to anxiety, defiance, or simply not being developmentally ready, can lead to prolonged training periods and frustration.

Lastly, the ‘Oh Crap’ method, while popular, lacks a broad base of empirical support compared to other potty training techniques that might offer more flexibility or align better with a child’s unique developmental pace. This lack of evidence-based endorsement could leave parents second-guessing its effectiveness or suitability, particularly when faced with the practical challenges of extended training times and the emotional toll it can take on both the child and the family.

Comparing ‘Oh Crap’ to Other Potty Training Techniques

The ‘Oh Crap’ potty training method, while distinct, shares similarities with other approaches like the Big Little Feelings course. Both methods initiate with a phase of the child being naked to recognize and respond to bodily cues, followed by a transition to wearing underwear. Specifically, the Big Little Feelings strategy involves three full days of nakedness, which contrasts with the ‘Oh Crap’ method, where the initial phase might extend depending on the child’s readiness and the occurrence of frequent accidents. This difference highlights the ‘Oh Crap’ method’s flexibility but also its potential for extending the potty training duration if the child does not adapt quickly.

Another popular method is ‘Potty Training in 3 Days’, often compared with ‘Oh Crap’. Both are intensive, aiming to achieve quick results. However, there is no conclusive evidence suggesting that one method outperforms the other, leaving the choice largely to parental preference and the child’s responsiveness. Parents might find themselves choosing based on how the method’s structure aligns with their child’s temperament and their own daily routines.

Furthermore, the ‘waiting until ready’ approach presents a stark contrast to the ‘Oh Crap’ method. It advocates for starting potty training only when the child shows clear signs of readiness, such as consistent dry nights, the desire to be changed immediately after soiling, and communicating the need to use the toilet. This method can often lead to a quicker and less stressful potty training experience since it is aligned with the child’s natural developmental pace, unlike the ‘Oh Crap’ method, which is more prescriptive and proactive. Each method has its merits and challenges, and its effectiveness can vary significantly from one child to another, influenced by individual readiness and family lifestyle.

Mom Wonders Why Family Won’t Babysit Daughter, Grandma Reveals Secret

Real Parent Experiences and Success Stories

In various online forums, parents have shared their experiences with the ‘Oh Crap’ Potty Training Method, providing a spectrum of insights that range from high praise to cautious optimism. Many parents have noted the method’s effectiveness, especially when they closely followed Jamie Glowacki’s guidelines and adapted them to their child’s unique cues and readiness. One parent detailed their success story with their 23-month-old daughter, emphasizing the importance of patience and the ability to read their child’s signs, which were crucial in smoothly transitioning from diapers to using the potty.

Practical Tips from Experienced Parents

  1. Preparation is key. Covering play areas with vinyl tablecloths to manage accidents during the early days.
  2. Engagement and Distraction: Allowing the child to watch movies or engage in favorite activities during potty times will keep them relaxed and cooperative.
  3. Equipment Choices: Opting for user-friendly potty equipment like the Baby Bjorn toilet seat, which many found easy for their children to use independently,.

These strategies highlight the practical aspects of implementing the ‘Oh Crap’ method, tailored to individual family dynamics and child behaviors. By sharing these tips, parents contribute to a collective knowledge base that can aid new parents in navigating the potty training journey with more confidence and less stress.

Must-Have Board Games for Fun Family Game Night


Through careful evaluation, the ‘Oh Crap’ Potty Training method has emerged as a highly structured yet flexible approach that many modern parents find effective in navigating the challenging but essential journey of potty training. By prioritizing the recognition of bodily cues and promoting autonomy, Jamie Glowacki’s method not only aids children in the transition away from diapers but also encourages a deeper parental engagement in their child’s developmental milestones. This engagement is crucial in fostering an environment of trust and confidence, essential components for a successful potty training process. The method’s adaptability to various family dynamics and routines, along with its minimalistic approach requiring little more than a dedicated long weekend, a potty chair, and a commitment to following through each defined block, highlights its practicality for today’s parents.

However, despite its many advantages, the method is not without its challenges and is subject to criticism, chiefly regarding the level of commitment required from parents and the potential conflict with external schedules like daycare. Yet, the shared experiences of numerous families attest to the method’s effectiveness in achieving the desired independence in toilet use among children. As each child is unique, so too will be their potty training journey. Parents considering the ‘Oh Crap’ method should weigh both its benefits and potential drawbacks, adjusting as necessary to align with their child’s cues and developmental pace. Ultimately, the method reinforces the importance of patience, understanding, and consistency in guiding children through this significant developmental stage, offering a path that, while not devoid of obstacles, leads to a rewarding outcome of potty independence.

Signs of Potty Training Age and Regression


1. What potty training method do you most find effective? Many parents and experts find that the most effective potty training method involves the child being naked from the waist down during a three-day training period. This approach prevents confusion with diapers, as underwear can feel similar and may lead to accidents. Additionally, it simplifies the process of quickly getting the child to the toilet when necessary.

2. What are the essential items for potty training? For successful potty training, it is advisable to start with a potty chair. Place the potty chair in the bathroom or in the area where your child spends most of their time. Initially, let your child sit on the potty chair while clothed to get accustomed to it. Ensure the child’s feet can reach the floor or a stool, and always use positive language when referring to the toilet and the process.

3. What is an effective routine for potty training? An effective potty training routine involves taking your child to the bathroom at regular intervals throughout the day. Setting a timer for every hour or hour and a half to remind them to use the toilet can be helpful. This frequent practice helps the child develop the habit of using the bathroom for their needs.

4. What is the recommended approach and age for starting toilet training? The recommended age to start toilet training is around 2 years old, as starting as early as 13 months is generally considered too early. Begin by explaining and demonstrating the use of the toilet, emphasizing that using the toilet is what older individuals do. Explain the transition from diapers to using the toilet and wearing underwear as part of becoming ‘big’.

5. What is the general rhythm of the ‘Oh Crap’ potty training method?The ‘Oh Crap’ method, developed by social worker and potty-training expert Jamie Glowacki, author of the book “Oh Crap! Potty Training,” is structured into blocks. The first block starts with the child learning to use the potty while naked before progressing to more complex stages like using the potty with clothes on and eventually moving to nighttime training.

6. When is the best time to start potty training using the ‘Oh Crap’ method?The best time to begin is when your child is between 20 to 30 months of age. This period is ideal as it taps into the toddler’s developmental readiness to leave diapers behind.

7. Why are pull-ups not recommended in the ‘Oh Crap’ method?Pull-ups can confuse children because they mimic diapers, making it harder for them to understand the transition to regular toilet use. Jamie Glowacki advises using training pants or going straight to underwear after the initial naked phase.

8. How does the ‘Oh Crap’ method address nighttime training?Nighttime training is one of the latter phases of the method. It encourages parents to recognize their child’s natural development and readiness, suggesting that night training often starts after daytime potty reliability is established.

9. Can you explain the blocks in the ‘Oh Crap’ potty training method?The method includes several blocks, starting with the child being naked, introducing clothing, mastering the potty with clothes, and finally managing potty use independently during the day and night. Each block builds upon the last, reinforcing skills and confidence.

10. What are some tips for parents during the first week of potty training?The first week can involve a lot of stress and accidents. It’s important to stay calm, keep the mood upbeat, and spend the entire day observing the child’s cues closely. Small outings can begin towards the end of the first week as the child becomes more comfortable with the potty.

11. Is the ‘Oh Crap’ method suitable for older toddlers or only young children?This method works best for children approximately 20 to 30 months old but can also be adapted for older toddlers. Older kids might already show signs of readiness and may move through the blocks quicker than younger children.

12. How do you handle potty training on longer trips or outings?For longer outings, prepare by bringing a portable potty or finding regular bathrooms along your route. Pack extra clothes and a plastic bag for any soiled items to manage accidents without added stress.

13. What should parents do if they feel there is a power struggle during potty training?If a power struggle arises, it might be a good time to take a break and reassess. Sometimes stepping back for a few days or even a couple of weeks can help reset the situation. Continuously pushing when there is a lot of resistance might turn potty training into a negative experience for both the child and the parent.

14. Can potty training be fun for children?Absolutely! Incorporating fun elements like sticker charts, favorite books, or singing songs can make potty training an enjoyable time. These tools not only motivate but also keep the spirits high during what can be a challenging learning process.

15. What if my child regresses after being potty-trained?Regression can happen for several reasons, such as stress, a new sibling, or changes in the routine. It’s important to go back to the basics of the ‘Oh Crap’ method, revisit the block that matches your child’s current needs, and provide lots of praise and encouragement to get back on track.

These FAQs aim to cover a broad spectrum of queries regarding the ‘Oh Crap’ potty training method, offering guidance, tips, and reassurance to parents embarking on this journey with their little ones.

Top Tips to Make Your Coffee Healthier